click here to print the catering menu

Catering Menu

Let Us Help You Enjoy Your Special Event



From christenings to retirement parties Bench Warmers catering will allow you to enjoy your event with your guests, instead of cooking. We can provide most of our menu items, catering specials or create a customized menu for the event. Great food, great price, delivery, setup, chafing pans and Sterno are among the services we can offer.

Sit back, relax and enjoy!

You may add additional items to any package
Appetizers 1.00 per person
Sides 1.50 per person
Entrees 2.00 per person
Dessert 1.00 per person

Party Trays are available
Chafing Pans and Sterno are available for an additional charge
Prices Subject to Change
Prices Effective October 2008

Kick Off Party

Pricing for Minimum 20 People

6.95 per person includes:
Cheryl’s Fried Chicken

Choice of Homemade Potato Salad or Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
Choice of Homemade Baked Beans, Seasonal Veggies or Buttered Corn
Choice of Homemade Cole Slaw or Fresh Garden Salad with House Dressing
Rolls with Butter and Margarine
Place Settings and Serving Utensils

Game Day Party

Pricing for Minimum 20 People

7.95 per person includes:
Cheryl’s Fried Chicken
Mostaccioli with Meat Sauce
Roast Beef in Gravy or Aujus

Choice of Homemade Potato Salad or Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
Choice of Homemade Baked Beans, Seasonal Veggies, or Buttered Corn
Choice of Homemade Cole Slaw or Fresh Garden Salad with House Dressing
Rolls with Butter and Margarine
Place Settings and Serving Utensils

Tail Gate Picnic

Pricing for Minimum 20 People

8.95 per person includes:
Cheryl’s Fried Chicken
Bench Burgers and Buns
1/4lb Hot Dogs and Buns

Homemade Potato Salad
Homemade Baked Beans
Homemade Cole Slaw
Ketchup, Mustard, Relish and Onions
Place Settings and Serving Utensils

Super Bowl Party

Pricing for Minimum 20 People

9.95 per person includes:
Buffalo Wings
Swedish Meatballs
Cheryl’s Fried Chicken
Choice of Ham or Beef
Choice of Mostaccioli,
Sausage & Peppers,
or Polish Sausage & Sauerkraut

Choice of Homemade Potato Salad, or Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Choice of Homemade Baked Beans, Seasonal Veggies, or Buttered Corn
Choice of Homemade Cole Slaw, or Fresh Garden Salad with House Dressing
Rolls with Butter and Margarine
Place Settings and Serving Utensils

Create Your Own

Pricing for Minimum 20 People

9.95 per person includes:

Choose An Appetizer

Buffalo Wings
Lil’ Smokies
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Swedish Meatballs
Buffalo Shrimp (add 50¢ per person)

Choose Two Entrees

Baked Ham
Chicken Marsala
Mostaccioli
Lasagna
Roast Beef
Sausage & Peppers
Sausage & Sauerkraut
Garlic Lemon Chicken*
Chicken Parmigana*
Cheryl’s Fried Chicken
Smothered Chicken*
Blackened Chicken Pasta*
Pasta ala Kaitlyn*
Creole Combo*
Chicken Vesuvio*
Pepper Steak*
Chicken Piccata*
*These items are an additional 1.00 per person

Choose Three Sides

Fresh Garden Salad & House Dressing
Baked Potato
Potato Salad
Seasonal Vegetables
Cole Slaw
Buttered Corn
Pasta Salad
Baked Beans
Cottage Cheese
Green Bean Casserole
Macaroni & Cheese
Vesuvio Potatoes
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
White Cheddar Mashed

Choose A Dessert

Sheet Cake
Brownies
Ice Cream
Pudding
Cheesecake
Cookies

Includes Rolls with Butter and Margarine
Place Settings and Serving Utensils

Cheryl’s Fried Chicken

8 piece
6.80
20 piece
16.95
30 piece
25.50
40 piece
33.95
50 piece
42.50
60 piece
47.95
70 piece
55.95
80 piece
63.95
90 piece
71.95
100 piece
79.95
150 piece
119.95
200 piece
159.95

Buffalo Wings

50 Piece
25.99
100 Piece
49.99
150 Piece
69.99
200 Piece
89.99

Buffalo Chicken Strips

Two Pounds
20.99
Five Pounds
48.99
Ten Pounds
89.99
Twenty Pounds
169.99

Buffalo Shrimp

50 Piece
28.99
100 Piece
57.99
150 Piece
286.99
200 Piece
115.99

Your choice of Plain, Mild, Hot, Insane, Hickory BBQ, Chipotle BBQ, Jack Daniels BBQ,
Teriyaki, Honey Mustard, Sweet & Sour, and Garlic & Herb sauces.

Ala Carte Entrees

1/2 pan serves approximately 10-15 people
full pan serves approximately 20-30 people

Baked Ham
full pan 59.95
1/2 pan 29.95 -
Mostaccioli
full pan 39.95
1/2 pan 19.95 -
Roast Beef
full pan 89.95
1/2 pan 44.95 -
Sausage & Peppers
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Sausage & Sauerkraut
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Chicken Marsala
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Chicken Vesuvio
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Chicken Piccata
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Garlic Lemon Chicken
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Chicken Parmigana
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Smothered Chicken
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Blackened Chicken Pasta
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Lasagna
full pan 58.95
1/2 pan 24.95 -
Pasta ala Kaitlyn
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Creole Combo
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Pepper Steak
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -

Ala Carte Sides

Potato Salad
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
Cole Slaw
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
Pasta Salad
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
Macaroni & Cheese
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
White Cheddar Mashed
full pan 34.95
1/2 pan 17.95 -
Fresh Garden Salad
full pan 36.95
1/2 pan 18.95 -
Seasonal Veggies
full pan 44.95
1/2 pan 22.95 -
Buttered Corn
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
Baked Beans
full pan 28.95
1/2 pan 14.95 -
Green Bean Casserole
full pan 36.95
1/2 pan 18.95 -
Vesuvio Potatoes
full pan 34.95
1/2 pan 17.95 -
Lil’ Smokies
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Swedish Meatballs
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -
Spinach Artichoke Dip
full pan 68.95
1/2 pan 34.95 -

Lets Get The Party Started!